Lyfe Fuel vs. Shakeology: Which One Should You Choose?

With so many nutrition shakes vying for your attention, picking the right one can feel like a guessing game. If you're comparing Lyfe Fuel vs. Shakeology, we’re here to cut through the noise. 

This guide breaks down key differences—ingredients, nutrition, taste, price—so you can find a shake that fits your lifestyle and wellness goals.

Quick Verdict: Lyfe Fuel vs. Shakeology

Torn between Lyfe Fuel vs. Shakeology? Here’s your shortcut to selecting the right meal replacement shake: 

• Choose Lyfe Fuel if you want a shake that uses all-natural, plant-based ingredients in their most bioavailable form for a reasonable price. 

• Choose Shakeology if you want a more calorie-dense shake that comes in a wider range of flavors and lets you choose between vegan and whey protein versions.
  

Not sold on either option? Maximum Vibrance from Vibrant Health may be a better fit. This decadent protein and greens powder doubles as a multivitamin and meal replacement shake, thanks to its powerful blend of protein, probiotics, and micronutrients. Plus, it's available in two indulgent flavors: Chocolate Chunk and Vanilla Bean.

Read More: Shakeology vs. Maximum Vibrance: What’s Better for You? 

What Is Lyfe Fuel?

Lyfe Fuel creates convenient nutrition products that feature clean, all-natural ingredients. Its plant-based Daily Essentials Shake is designed to support a healthy metabolism and weight management.

This shake contains over 50 bioavailable superfoods, providing ample vitamins, minerals, probiotics, digestive enzymes, and antioxidants. It acts as a multivitamin, protein powder, and greens supplement all in one.

Pros of Life Fuel:

• 50+ plant-based ingredients

• Uses methylated B12 and chelated minerals, which are more bioavailable 

• Contains D3, K2, and CO-Q10

• Provides 960 million CFUs of probiotics

• Free from soy, gluten, seed oils, and artificial flavors

• Third-party tested

• Affordable price

• 30-day “Happiness Guarantee”

Cons of Life Fuel:

• Only available in two flavors 

• Slightly less sweet than other meal replacement shakes

• Uses proprietary blends, so you can’t see its exact ingredient amounts

What Is Shakeology?

Shakeology is a popular meal replacement shake created by BODi (formerly Beachbody), a health and nutrition company that also offers online fitness programs and supplements. BODi claims this shake can help support healthy weight loss, digestion, and energy levels.

Whether you prefer whey or plant-based protein, Shakeology has a formulation that can meet your needs. Both options deliver a comprehensive blend of vitamins, minerals, probiotics, digestive enzymes, and adaptogens in every serving.

Pros of Shakeology:

• Broad range of vitamins and minerals

• 2 billion CFUs of probiotics per serving

• Free from gluten, soy, and artificial ingredients

• Third-party tested and manufactured in a Good Manufacturing Practice-certified facility

• 0 Grams Added Sugar option available

• 31-day money-back guarantee

Cons of Shakeology: 

• Higher in sugar, carbs, and calories than other meal replacement shakes

• Mixed reviews regarding its flavor and mixability

• High price

• Uses proprietary blends

Discover More: 7 Shakeology Alternatives: Which One Is Right For You?

Ingredients and Nutritional Comparison

When evaluating meal replacement shakes, you want to pay close attention to how much nutrition you get per calorie. This way, you can maximize your nourishment while supporting your weight loss goals.

With that in mind, let’s examine how Lyfe Fuel vs. Shakeology stack up in terms of nutrition:

• Lyfe Fuel – Lyfe Fuel contains 110 calories, 6 grams of carbs, 2 grams of fat, and 18 grams of protein per serving. All of its ingredients are plant-based, so it's suitable for vegans and vegetarians. Due to its low carbs, it may also work well for those following a keto diet. Most notably, Lyfe Fuel uses ingredients in their most bioavailable form.

• Shakeology – Depending on which protein type and flavor you choose, Shakeology contains around 160 calories,18 grams of carbs, 2.5 grams of fat, and 17 grams of protein per serving. If you purchase the 0g Added Sugar version, you’ll receive a similar amount of protein for just 10 to 11 grams of carbs. Shakeology provides a wide range of vitamins and minerals, though its daily values are lower than Lyfe Fuel’s. 

While both shakes pack a lot of nutrition into each serving, Lyfe Fuel stands out for its highly bioavailable ingredients, impressive daily nutrient values, and lower calories and carbohydrates.

Discover More: 6 Best Vegan Protein Powders Based on Science 

Taste, Texture, and Mixability

Meal replacement shakes aren’t just meant to fuel your body—they can also satisfy your sweet tooth, making your weight loss journey more enjoyable and sustainable. That’s why taste and texture matter just as much as nutrition.

In our taste test, Life Fuel took the lead. While it's only available in two flavors—Vanilla Chai and Chocolate—both are crave-worthy without being too sweet. Better yet, this shake blends well whether you use a blender or a shaker and comes out delightfully smooth. 

Shakeology’s whey protein and low-sugar flavor options are similarly limited. You can only choose between Chocolate and Vanilla. However, its vegan version also comes in Tropical Strawberry, Cookies & Creamy, and Cafe Latte. Where Shakeology falls short is its aftertaste and texture. Some users report that it's overly sweet, slightly artificial tasting, and chalky. 

Price and Value for Money

Drinking your meal replacement shake daily often yields the best results, so it’s important to choose one you can enjoy regularly without straining your budget.

Here’s a side-by-side look at how Lyfe Fuel vs Shakeology compare when it comes to pricing:

• Lyfe Fuel – One bag of Lyfe Fuel costs $70 and contains 24 servings. This breaks down to around $2.91 per shake. If you subscribe for regular deliveries, you can save 14%, streamlining the cost per serve to just $2.50—nearly half of what you’ll pay for a Starbucks Latte. Better yet, you can get a full refund if you’re not satisfied within the first 30 days.
  
  

• Shakeology – One bag of Shakeology provides 30 servings for $129.95, which is around $4.33 per scoop. This places Shakeology on the premium end of the meal replacement shake pricing spectrum. Fortunately, Shakeology offers a similar risk-free guarantee to ensure your satisfaction. You have 31 days to return the product and get your money back if you’re not happy with it. 

Since Lyfe Fuel offers more vitamins and minerals than Shakeology at a lower price, it’s the better overall value for money. However, Shakeology contains more calories, which may be appealing if you’re seeking a more filling meal replacement shake. 

Read More: Ka'Chava VS Shakeology, What is the Better Supplement? 

Shakeology vs. Lyfe Fuel: Which One Should You Choose?

Lyfe Fuel and Shakeology can both help you incorporate satiating nutrition, gut health support, and a touch of sweetness into your day, all while keeping your calories in check.

If you want to keep your carbs and overall costs low, Lyfe Fuel delivers exceptional nutrition and clean ingredients at an affordable price. On the other hand, if you want more flavor options or prefer whey protein, Shakeology may be the better fit for your needs.

Lyfe Fuel or Shakeology Don’t Cut it? Get Maximum Vibrance 

Maximum Vibrance by Vibrant Health could be the nutrient-dense upgrade your routine needs. With 20g of plant-based protein, a full spectrum of vitamins and minerals, 25 billion probiotics, and zero proprietary blends, it’s designed for maximum transparency and total-body support. Available in rich Chocolate Chunk and smooth Vanilla Bean, it’s a premium daily shake that delivers where others fall short.