Shakeology vs. Maximum Vibrance: What’s Better for You?

Shakeology vs. Maximum Vibrance: What’s Better for You?

In today's fast-paced world, maintaining a healthy diet can be challenging, leading many to turn to fast food or snacks lacking in nutrients. 

To address this, numerous companies such as Beachbody and Vibrant Health now offer streamlined options such as protein powder to ensure optimal nutrition for those on the go. Among these are Maximum Vibrance and Shakeology, two of the most popular options offering quality protein powders. 

To help you understand their differences and which one is ideal for your unique needs, we’ve tested both products and analyzed them based on their pricing, flavors, effectiveness, and other factors.

Jump straight to:

Shakeology by Beachbody 

Shakeology, a flagship product of Beachbody, stands as a popular protein powder within the wellness community. Popularly known for their at-home fitness programs like P90X and Insanity, Beachbody created Shakeology to address the growing need for convenient yet nutritious dietary solutions and over the years has gained widespread recognition.

Developed by a team of experts, Shakeology offers a dynamic blend of vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, probiotics, and other nutrients. It is promoted as a “superfood nutrition shake” that’s claimed to assist with weight loss, reduce cravings of highly processed foods, boost energy levels, and support healthier overall digestion.

  • Beachbody prioritizes fair trade practices and strives for pesticide-free sourcing, ensuring ingredients are produced fairly.
  • Lacks GMO-free certification, yet actively avoids GMO ingredients, including soy, canola, and corn, highlighting a commitment to product purity.
  • Engages in social justice efforts by supporting Feeding America, International Justice Mission (IJM), NAACP, and the Red Cross.

Shakeology Nutritional Profile

While there are available in a range of flavors and customizable options to suit various dietary preferences and needs, there has been a discussion whether the ingredients and quality are “overhyped”. Before we draw any conclusions let’s dive in to the facts.

They do not practice full-disclosure labeling. Instead, they utilize proprietary blends, meaning they do not disclose the exact amount of each ingredient present in the shake. However, each ingredient is listed in order of predominance within the formula on the label. 

  • Vitamins and minerals: Vitamins A, B6, B12, C, D, E, K2; Biotin, Calcium, Magnesium, Zinc, Selenium, Sodium, Thiamine, Riboflavin, Folate, Chromium, Phosphorus, Iodine, and Iron.
  • Additives & sweeteners: Contains no artificial sweeteners, flavors, colors, or preservatives. Has about 7 grams of sugar from a combination of organic cane sugar and various superfood fruit powders.
  • Macros: 160 calories, 17g of protein, 2.5g of fat, 7g of sugar, 6g of fiber
  • Probiotic strains/CFU: Proprietary blend of prebiotics and probiotics, including coagulants to help support a healthy gut and digestion.

Shakeology Taste & Texture

It comes in 9 flavors ranging from chocolate and vanilla to strawberry and coffee. flavors.

Among the diverse palette, the Chocolate Vegan distinctly stands out, delivering a deep, indulgent chocolate experience that is both rich and creamy. Another flavor that caught our attention was the Strawberry Vegan, offering a refreshingly light taste.

We couldn't help but notice the Tropical Strawberry flavor left a noticeably bitter aftertaste, something that might be a consideration for those sensitive to such nuances in flavor profiles.

Shakeology Mixability

We found that simpler shakes made with Shakeology and liquid can be easily mixed in a shaker cup. For those who prefer a thicker texture, we experimented with alternatives including unsweetened almond milk, reduced-fat (2%) milk, unsweetened oat milk, and unsweetened organic soy milk. These options blend seamlessly with Shakeology, offering a delightful, creamy consistency that enhances the overall taste.

Shakeology Usability

By offering an ample selection of vegan flavor options, Shakeology is suitable for those following plant-based lifestyles. And while it isn’t officially certified as GMO-free or gluten-free, we noted that its ingredients do seem to align with gluten-free dietary requirements.

It’s recommended to mix 1 scoop of Shakeology with 8 to 12 ounces of water, juice, milk, or nut milk, and take it once or twice a day depending on your individual nutritional needs or goals.

Shakeology Cost

Shakeology offers a health shake priced at $129.95 for a one-time purchase, breaking down to $4.33 per serving. For those looking for a more cost-effective option, signing up as a Partner or Preferred Customer grants access to a monthly subscription rate of $103.96. Both purchasing options provide a 30-day supply.

  • One-time purchase cost: $129.95 30-day supply, $4.33 per serving 
  • Monthly subscription cost: $103.96 for Partner or Preferred Customer 

Shakeology Customer Reviews

Shakeology offers an easy on-the-go solution for those who might be tempted to reach for fast food. However, the company often refers to Shakeology as a meal replacement while some customers argue they are perpetuating diet culture. One criticism is that there is no transparent labeling to know exactly how much of each nutrient is present. 

Users report Beachbody’s customer service being very difficult to get a hold of and a challenge to cancel both orders and subscriptions.

Who Is Shakeology Best For?

  • Those looking to curb cravings: Ideal for individuals seeking a nutritious way to manage hunger and reduce the temptation of unhealthy snacking throughout the day.
  • Those who live an on-the-go lifestyle: Perfect for busy individuals needing a quick and healthy meal replacement that fits seamlessly into their fast-paced daily routines.
  • Those following a Beachbody program: Especially beneficial for participants in Beachbody fitness programs, offering them a nutritional supplement at a discounted rate to complement their workout regimen.

Shakeology, Is It Worth It?

Shakeology is marketed as a nutritional shake with potential benefits, including weight loss. However, many of the bold health claims associated with it lack substantial scientific evidence to support them and without transparent labeling, you don’t know the full scope of nutrients you are getting in each shake. 

While incorporating Shakeology into your diet isn't detrimental and may offer some nutritional advantages over highly processed alternatives, there are other higher quality and budget friendly options available.

It's essential for consumers to approach marketing claims with skepticism and explore alternative choices that align with their health and budget priorities.

Maximum Vibrance by Vibrant Health

As a company, Vibrant Health has a strong reputation for using the best high-quality ingredients and being transparent about the ingredients they use with full-disclosure labeling. They do not utilize any proprietary blends so users know exactly what they’re getting when they take their supplements.

  • Maximum Vibrance undergoes third-party testing, with all ingredients ethically sourced and available in eco-friendly pouches.
  • While not all ingredients can achieve organic certification, Vibrant Health ensures as many as possible are certified organic, going beyond standard measures.
  • The company supports under-served communities and social justice initiatives through partnerships with Vitamin Angel, Feeding America, and offering education scholarships.
Shop Maximum Vibrance

Read more: Why Vibrant Health?

Maximum Vibrance Nutritional Profile

Maximum Vibrance is Vibrant Health’s all-in-one future-forward supplement. Boasting a comprehensive blend of nutrients from over 120 ingredients, this supplement is packed with vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, and 20 grams of plant-powered protein.

If you’re looking for a highly nutrient-dense shake on the market, this should be your next purchase. They are one of the rare brands that participate in full-disclosure labeling where every ingredient used is listed, precisely disclosing the amount in which it is present.  

  • Vitamins and minerals: Contains a wide range of vitamins and minerals supporting a healthy immune system, including Vitamin C, A, and B complex; Zinc, Iron, Calcium, Magnesium and more.
  • Additives and sweeteners: No added sweeteners, fillers, or gums
  • Macros: 150 calories, 20g of protein, 3g of fat, 10g of carbs, 3g of sugar 
  • Probiotic strains/CFU: Contains 25 billion CFU per 2 scoops including Bifidobacterium Longum, a probiotic naturally occurring in yogurt that supports digestive health, helps maintain healthy cholesterol levels, and promotes immune health. 

Maximum Vibrance Taste & Texture

Maximum Vibrance is available in two flavors: Vanilla Bean and Chocolate Chunk.

Both flavors of carry a distinct “grassy” undertone because of the rich mix of green superfoods like spirulina and wheatgrass. Despite this, you can be creative with it and use it in your daily rotation. For example, you can whip up a Max Vibrance Chocolate Protein Smoothie, a homemade recipe that beautifully masks the grassy notes with a rich, chocolatey delight. 

And while the slight grassy aftertaste is there, it's mild and easily blendable into flavorful concoctions.

Maximum Vibrance Mixability

Maximum Vibrance is quite versatile so it  is very easily mixed with water, fruit juice, almond milk or made into a smoothie depending on your preferences.

Maximum Vibrance Usability

It's gluten-free, plant-based, soy-free, vegan-friendly, and dairy-free, making it a suitable option for almost everyone.

For daily use, you can use it as a complete and light meal replacement. Mixing two level scoops into 8 to 16 ounces of water or your preferred beverage offers a satisfying, full meal. While one scoop serves as a lighter alternative. For optimum benefits, it’s best enjoyed as a standalone meal, or 30 to 45 minutes after eating.

Stirring briskly or shaking in a closed container guarantees a smooth mix.

Maximum Vibrance Cost

Maximum Vibrance presents a competitively priced health shake option at $90 for a one-time purchase, equating to $3 per serving. For ongoing enthusiasts, a monthly subscription offers a reduced rate of $68.60 for a 30-day supply. This pricing model positions Maximum Vibrance as an affordable alternative, without sacrificing nutritional value.

When comparing Maximum Vibrance to Shakeology, it's clear that Maximum Vibrance offers a more economical choice, both for one-time purchases and monthly subscriptions.

  • One-time purchase cost: $90 30-day supply, $3 per serving 
  • Monthly subscription: $68.60 for 30-day supply

Maximum Vibrance Customer Reviews

Customers report that this is one of the most nutrient-dense protein powders on the market that comes with the enzymes to digest it. Users have also reported feeling energetic, more alert, and overall better without the energy crashes. The only complaint is the taste, but long times users have learned how to negate it by mixing it with fruits and veggies.

The consensus is that this product is one of the best protein powders on the market if you prioritize your health and don’t look for shortcuts.

Who Is Maximum Vibrance Best For?

  • Athletes and Fitness Enthusiasts: Max Vibrance provides a blend of protein, vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, probiotics, and digestive enzymes, which can support muscle recovery, energy levels, and overall performance during workouts.
  • Busy Professionals: For individuals with hectic lifestyles or irregular eating habits, Max Vibrance offers a convenient way to ensure they're getting essential nutrients without having to prepare elaborate meals.
  • Health-Conscious Consumers: Max Vibrance contains organic ingredients and avoids artificial additives, making it a preferred choice for those prioritizing clean and natural supplements in their diet.
  • People With Dietary Restrictions: Max Vibrance is gluten-free, soy-free, and dairy-free, catering to individuals with specific dietary sensitivities or allergies.

Maximum Vibrance, Is It Worth It?

Max Vibrance by Vibrant Health stands out as an excellent choice for a nutrient-dense shake for several compelling reasons including their transparent, high-quality ingredients. While some may find that it has a mildly grassy taste, there are a wide variety of ways to delicious ways to incorporate it. 

Max Vibrance is designed to deliver a balanced blend of macronutrients (carbohydrates, proteins, and fats) along with micronutrients (vitamins and minerals). This balance helps support energy levels, muscle recovery, and overall well-being.

With added digestive enzymes and probiotics, Maximum Vibrance promotes optimal digestion and gut health, serving as a quick and easy meal replacement or a nutritious snack on the go, saving time without compromising on quality nutrition.

Overall, Maximum Vibrance provides a convenient and effective way to enhance your daily nutrient intake, supporting your overall health and well-being. Its comprehensive formula, high-quality ingredients, and versatile usage make it a standout option for those seeking a nutrient-dense shake.


  • Full-disclosure labeling 
  • 25 billion CFU/probiotics to support gut health
  • High content of antioxidants and minerals 
  • Cheaper than Shakeology


  • Less flavors to choose from 
  • Has a slightly grassy taste on its own

Shakeology vs. Maximum Vibrance: Which Comes Out on Top?

When comparing Beachbody's Shakeology to Vibrant Health's Max Vibrance, it's essential to consider various factors such as:

  • Transparent labels: Max Vibrance utilizes full disclosure labeling for all of their ingredients and no proprietary blends while Shakeology uses proprietary blends, leaving consumers in the dark about exactly what they are getting.
  • Nutritional profile: Max Vibrance from Vibrant Health emerges as the superior choice for several reasons. Max Vibrance offers a broader spectrum of nutrients, including vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, probiotics, and digestive enzymes, making it a more comprehensive option for overall health and wellness.
  • Value: Maximum Vibrance provides higher nutritional value at a considerably lower price.

Additionally, Maximum Vibrance contains mostly organic ingredients and top-tier probiotic strains which aligns with the preferences of many health-conscious consumers.

Overall, Maximum Vibrance stands out for its nutritional transparency, ethical sourcing, affordability, and the comprehensive range of nutrients it provides. Shakeology offers diverse flavors and a strong connection to an established fitness community but falls short with its proprietary blends and higher price point.

Shop Maximum Vibrance
DISCLAIMER: This information is not intended as a substitute for advice provided by a competent healthcare professional. You should not use this information in diagnosing or treating a health problem. No claim or opinion in this blog is intended to be, nor should be construed to be, medical advice. If you are now taking any drugs, prescribed or not, or have a medical condition, please consult a competent physician who is aware of herb/drug interactions before taking any herbal supplements. The information presented herein has not been evaluated by the FDA or the Department of Health and is not intended to diagnose, prevent, cure, mitigate or treat any disease or illness.